Orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators (QMEs) evaluate the disputed medical issues in a California workers’ compensation claim involving the bones, joints, soft tissue, or spine. They give opinions on whether the injury came from work, rate any permanent impairment, and apportion that impairment between work and other causes. They also address temporary disability, work restrictions, and future medical care.
So what does that look like in practice? Below, we cover each question the evaluator answers and how the evaluator measures each answer. We also cover what the report leaves to the parties.
At a glance
- Scope: bones, joints, soft tissue, and spine, from single-event injuries to cumulative trauma.
- Core issues: causation, disability status, impairment, apportionment, restrictions, and future care.
- Rating method: the AMA Guides, Fifth Edition, as adopted by California’s rating schedule.
- Deadline: 30 days from the exam, with limited extensions.
- Role: neutral medical opinions only, with no treatment and no benefit decisions.
Which injuries do orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators handle?
Orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators handle injuries to the bones, joints, ligaments, tendons, muscles, and spine. That includes harm from one event, such as a fall. It also includes cumulative trauma, which builds over months or years of repeated work, such as lifting or reaching overhead.
Common body parts on an orthopaedic panel include the neck, lower back, shoulders, elbows, wrists, hands, hips, knees, and ankles. Say a claim involves the neck and both shoulders. In that case, one orthopaedic QME addresses each body part in the same evaluation. However, psychiatric or internal medicine claims go to evaluators in those specialties.
Subspecialty focus also matters. OrthoLegal’s network covers general orthopaedics, spine, and hand. The OrthoLegal physician directory lists each doctor’s focus.
What medical-legal questions does an orthopaedic QME answer?
An orthopaedic QME answers the disputed medical issues that fall within the doctor’s specialty. The Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC) lists the core issues, from causation and temporary disability to apportionment and future care. Each one below calls for a stated opinion and the reasoning behind it.
- Causation: whether the injury arose out of and in the course of employment (AOE/COE).
- Temporary disability: how long the worker could not do usual job duties.
- Maximal medical improvement (MMI): the point when the condition has stabilized, also called permanent and stationary status.
- Permanent impairment: a whole person impairment rating for each body part under the AMA Guides.
- Apportionment: the share of disability caused by the work injury versus other factors (Labor Code sections 4663 and 4664).
- Work restrictions: the physical limits that shape return-to-work decisions.
- Future medical care: the treatment the condition will need going forward.
The parties frame these questions, and a report that skips one usually draws a supplemental request and delay. We explain what makes a QME medical-legal report useful to attorneys in a separate post. For how OrthoLegal sets up these evaluations, see our Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME) services.
How do orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators measure permanent impairment?
Orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators rate lasting impairment with the AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, Fifth Edition. That is the edition California’s Schedule for Rating Permanent Disabilities uses. The doctor then turns exam findings into a whole person impairment (WPI) score for each body part.
Each body region follows its own chapter. Spine ratings fall under Chapter 15, which relies mainly on the Diagnosis-Related Estimate (DRE) method. In contrast, upper extremity ratings follow Chapter 16, and lower extremity ratings follow Chapter 17.
Every rating rests on measured findings. Range of motion, strength, sensation, reflexes, and imaging all feed the number. Because of this, the report should link each finding to the rating. That way, both sides trace every percentage back to the exam.
Still, the WPI is not the final number. The rating schedule turns it into a permanent disability rating. Along the way, it adjusts for future earning capacity, job type, and age.
How do orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators approach cumulative trauma claims?
In a cumulative trauma claim, orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators look at the whole work history, not one event. First, they compare job duties, the timeline of symptoms, and the medical file. Then they form an opinion on whether repeated work caused or added to the condition, and they explain why.
These claims put extra weight on the history. For instance, job descriptions, years in each role, and the physical demands of the work all feed the cause analysis. Old imaging matters too, since wear and tear that predates the claim bears on apportionment.
Specific injuries follow a simpler path. The evaluator ties the condition to one event, such as a fall on a job site. Then the evaluator checks whether the records match that account.
Apportionment in cumulative trauma cases needs the most explanation. When a doctor splits disability between work and other causes, the report has to say how and why each cause plays a part. Otherwise, a bare percentage invites a request for a supplemental report.
What does the evaluator review before and during the exam?
The evaluation starts before the worker arrives, with a close look at the file. First, the orthopaedic QME reviews the medical records the parties serve. Next comes a detailed history, then a physical exam, and finally a comparison with imaging and diagnostic studies.
Record review sets the baseline. Treating physician reports, operative notes, imaging, and prior claim records show how the condition developed. They also carry weight on causation and apportionment, so gaps in the file show up in the report.
The exam itself centers on the disputed body parts. For a step-by-step look at the visit, read what happens during a workers’ comp QME evaluation. In addition, our guide to how the California QME panel process works covers the step before the appointment.
How long does an orthopaedic QME have to complete the report?
An orthopaedic QME has 30 days after the exam to complete the report. The rule sits in Title 8, California Code of Regulations, section 38. Extensions come only from the DWC Medical Director. They allow up to 30 more days for pending test results and up to 15 days for good cause.
Supplemental reports run on their own clock. The evaluator has 60 days from a written request. When both parties agree, that period extends by up to 30 days.
These deadlines drive the case calendar. That is why OrthoLegal builds its operations around quality, on-time reporting. Scheduling, records intake, and report support run through one team. As a result, the evaluator’s time stays on the exam and the analysis.
What does an orthopaedic QME not decide?
An orthopaedic QME gives medical opinions on the disputed issues and nothing more. The evaluator does not treat the worker, take either side, or award benefits. Instead, those decisions belong to the parties and, when they disagree, to the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board.
That neutrality is the point of the process. Applicant and defense attorneys rely on the same report. So its value rests on reasoning that either side can test against the record.
In short, clear logic and cited Guides chapters matter. So does a direct response to contrary evidence. Together, they let both sides weigh the report on its merits.
How does OrthoLegal support orthopaedic QME evaluations?
OrthoLegal handles scheduling, paperwork, and report support for orthopaedic QME and Agreed Medical Evaluator (AME) exams. Our evaluation locations span Northern, Central, and Southern California. Attorneys work with one team from the first request to the final report on each case.
See the OrthoLegal page for applicants and attorneys for our QME, AME, and related services. Then reach out to our team to book an orthopaedic exam.
Frequently asked questions
Do orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators assess more than one body part?
Yes. Orthopaedic Qualified Medical Evaluators address every musculoskeletal body part in dispute during the same evaluation. For example, a single report covers the lower back, a shoulder, and a knee when all three are in dispute. Each body part gets its own analysis of causation, impairment, and apportionment. The report then combines the ratings under the AMA Guides.
Is an orthopaedic QME the same as a treating physician?
No. A treating physician manages the worker’s care. An orthopaedic QME, by contrast, performs an independent medical-legal evaluation and provides no treatment. The QME examines the worker, reviews the record, and reports neutral opinions. Applicant and defense attorneys both rely on that report.
What happens when a QME report leaves out a disputed issue?
Either party requests a supplemental report in writing. Under Title 8, California Code of Regulations, section 38, the evaluator then has 60 days to respond. That period extends by up to 30 days when both parties agree. Parties also address open questions through a deposition of the evaluator.
Does the orthopaedic QME set the permanent disability percentage?
No. The orthopaedic QME reports a whole person impairment rating for each body part under the AMA Guides, Fifth Edition. That rating then converts to a permanent disability rating under California’s Schedule for Rating Permanent Disabilities. The conversion adjusts for future earning capacity, occupation, and age.


