QME vs AME

Person reviewing documents beside an open envelope containing cash on a wooden desk.

QME vs AME in California: Which Evaluation Applies to Your Case?

In California workers’ compensation, a Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME) is generally selected through a state-issued panel. An Agreed Medical Evaluator (AME) is chosen by agreement between the injured worker’s attorney and the defense. An AME can be used only when the worker has an attorney and both sides agree on the physician. Otherwise, the parties generally use the QME panel process.

OrthoLegal supports orthopaedic QME and AME evaluations across California. Below, we explain how each evaluator is selected and what attorneys should consider before agreeing to an AME.

QME vs AME: what is the difference?

The main difference is how the physician is selected for the case. A QME is certified by California’s Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC) to perform medical-legal evaluations and is generally selected from a panel of three physicians. An AME is chosen by agreement between the injured worker’s attorney and the defense.

Once chosen, the two do the same job. Both examine the worker, review the record and report on the contested medical issues, from causation to maximum medical improvement. The report deadline is also the same: 30 days after seeing the worker, unless the DWC Medical Director grants an extension (8 CCR 38).

When can the parties use an AME instead of a QME in California?

Close-up of a person typing on a laptop at a desk.

The parties can use an AME when the worker has an attorney and both sides agree on the physician. Labor Code 4062.2 lets them agree on an AME at any time, before or after a panel issues. The exception is any issue subject to independent medical review (IMR) under Labor Code 4610.5, the process for treatment disputes.

Timing shapes the QME vs AME decision as well. Section 4062.2 governs represented cases with injuries on or after January 1, 2005. A party may request a QME panel starting on the first working day at least 10 days after mailing an objection or evaluation request.

The DWC adds time for mailing. It treats a request made before 15 days have passed as premature, or before 20 days in out-of-state cases. The statute sets no separate period for AME discussions. Once the parties settle on an orthopaedic AME, OrthoLegal’s Agreed Medical Evaluator (AME) services cover scheduling and records intake.

How is each evaluator chosen?

A panel QME comes from a list of three physicians that the DWC Medical Unit issues on request. In a represented case, each side may strike one name, and the remaining physician serves. An unrepresented worker picks one of the three. For an AME, the applicant’s attorney and the defense agree on the physician.

Section 4062.2 and 8 CCR 30 set these steps for a represented panel:

  • Request: file online through the DWC Medical Unit system, naming the specialty and uploading the objection or evaluation request.
  • Panel: the system draws three QMEs at random from that specialty.
  • Service: within one working day after the panel issues, the requesting party serves the request, the panel and supporting papers on the other side.
  • Strikes: each side may strike one name within 10 days of service of the panel. If a party misses its strike, the other side may choose any remaining physician.
  • Appointment: the worker’s side arranges the exam. If it does not tell the employer of the appointment within 10 days after selection, the employer may arrange it.

Unrepresented cases use paper Form 105, mailed to the Medical Unit. The employer provides the form and asks the worker to submit it. If the worker has not done so within 10 days, the employer may file it instead. After the panel issues, the worker has 10 days to choose a physician, schedule the exam and tell the employer. If the worker does not report a choice in that time, the employer may select the physician.

An AME needs no panel request. Under Labor Code 4062.3, however, the parties must agree on what information the AME receives. Communications with the AME go in writing and are served on the other side when sent.

Does an AME report carry more weight than a QME report?

Close-up of a person typing on a laptop at a desk.

An AME’s opinion generally receives substantial consideration because both parties selected the physician for their expertise and neutrality. The Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) ordinarily follows that opinion but may reject it if it finds the reasoning unpersuasive.

Both AMEs and QMEs provide medical opinions rather than final legal decisions. The parties may resolve the claim by agreement, or the WCAB may decide unresolved disputes.

What do attorneys weigh before agreeing to an AME?

Attorneys on both sides look at the physician’s specialty, availability and reporting record. An AME also serves only if each side accepts the physician. Both sides weigh the commitment, too, since later disputes may return to the same evaluator. The QME vs AME choice, then, turns on the physician as much as the process.

  • Specialty fit: the parties can match an AME’s focus, such as spine or hand, to the disputed body parts. A panel, by comparison, draws from one designated specialty.
  • Availability: the report deadline runs from the exam, so the physician’s first open date shapes the case calendar.
  • Reporting record: each side considers whether the physician’s past reports arrived on time and answered every question asked.
  • Mutual acceptance: each side looks for reports that apply the AMA Guides consistently and explain each finding.
  • Commitment: under section 4062.3, the parties use the same evaluator for later medical disputes to the extent possible.

Can a California case move from a QME to an AME?

Yes. Represented parties may agree on an AME at any time under section 4062.2, even after a panel issues. When they do, the issued panel may be revoked under 8 CCR 30. The reverse move is narrower: no panel may be requested on an issue agreed to an AME unless both sides cancel the agreement in writing.

A change in representation does not reset the process. Under section 4062.1, a worker evaluated while unrepresented is not entitled to another evaluation after hiring an attorney. Likewise, section 4062.2 applies the same rule when a represented worker later stops being represented.

Frequently asked questions

Can an unrepresented worker use an AME?

No. Labor Code 4062.1 bars an employer from seeking an AME agreement with a worker who has no attorney. It also bars an AME from preparing the formal evaluation in that case. Instead, the worker’s route is a QME panel requested on Form 105. A worker with questions can contact the DWC Information and Assistance unit, which helps without charge.

Who pays for an AME in California?

The employer bears the cost. Under Labor Code 4064, the employer is liable for each reasonable and necessary medical-legal evaluation obtained under sections 4060, 4061 and 4062. The DWC medical-legal fee schedule, 8 CCR 9795, sets the billing values. For an evaluation by an AME, its modifier -94 multiplies the procedure’s normal value by 1.35. A panel QME evaluation carries modifier -95, which is for identification only and does not change the value.

What if the parties cannot agree on an AME?

The dispute goes to a QME panel. Once the waiting period after the objection or evaluation request ends, either side can request one online. The request must name the requesting party’s specialty, the other side’s preferred specialty if known, and the treating physician’s specialty. Even after the panel issues, the parties can agree on an AME.

How OrthoLegal supports QME and AME evaluations

Whichever way the QME vs AME decision goes, OrthoLegal supports the orthopaedic evaluation that follows. One team handles scheduling, records and report support for orthopaedic QME evaluations and AME exams. Evaluation sites span Northern, Central and Southern California, and our focus is quality, on-time reporting.

To request an evaluation, visit our services for applicants and attorneys or call 213.947.0000.

Request an Evaluation (button, links to /for-applicants-attorneys/)

This article is general information about California workers’ compensation, not legal or medical advice. For advice about a specific claim, talk to your attorney or the DWC Information and Assistance unit.

Loading calendar...