Addresses Causation
An AOE/COE denial means the claims administrator rejects a workers’ compensation claim, saying the injury did not arise out of employment (AOE) or occur in the course of employment (COE). When the dispute is medical, a Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME) or Agreed Medical Evaluator (AME) examines the worker and gives an opinion on causation. If the parties still disagree, a workers’ compensation judge decides.
OrthoLegal supports orthopaedic QME and AME evaluations across California. Our article on how AOE and COE work in California workers’ compensation explains the two tests. Here, we focus on the evaluation process after a denial.
What does an AOE/COE denial mean in California?
An AOE/COE denial is the claims administrator’s notice that it does not accept the injury as work related. Labor Code 3600 ties workers’ compensation liability to an injury arising out of and in the course of employment. It is one side’s position, not a judge’s ruling.
Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations (8 CCR), section 9812, sets the notice rules. A notice denying all benefits must go out within 14 days after the decision to deny and give the reasons. For a worker without an attorney, a denial on a medical issue also comes with the QME panel request form. The exception is a claim that has already had a medical-legal evaluation.
Some denials turn on facts rather than medicine, such as whether the worker was on duty. Those factual disputes are for the parties and, if needed, a judge.
Why might a cumulative trauma claim get an AOE/COE denial?
A cumulative trauma claim has no single event to point to. Labor Code 3208.1 defines a cumulative injury as repetitive mentally or physically traumatic activities over time that together cause disability or a need for treatment. Because the condition builds slowly, the link to work calls for medical analysis. That link is often what an AOE/COE denial disputes.
Several features of these claims can raise questions:
- Symptoms start gradually, so the history has to show how they developed alongside the work.
- Under Labor Code 5412, the date of injury is when the worker first suffered disability and knew, or reasonably should have known, that present or prior work caused it.
- Age-related wear, earlier injuries, other jobs and outside activities can affect the same body part.
- The work history may span years and several employers.
Still, none of these features settles the claim on its own. Our post on cumulative trauma injuries that build over time covers them in more depth.
What must a California claims administrator decide, and by when?
The claims administrator decides whether to accept or reject liability. Under Labor Code 5402, if liability is not rejected within 90 days after the claim form is filed, the injury is presumed compensable. Only evidence discovered after those 90 days can rebut that presumption. Some injuries listed in the statute have a 75-day period instead.
The same section covers medical care while the claim is pending:
- Within one working day after the claim form is filed, the employer must authorize treatment consistent with the state’s medical treatment guidelines.
- That treatment continues until liability is accepted or rejected. Until then, liability for it is limited to $10,000.
- Providing that treatment does not create a presumption of liability.
The Division of Workers’ Compensation (DWC) explains these rights in its answers to injured workers’ common questions. After an AOE/COE denial, either side can request a medical-legal evaluation on compensability.
How does a QME or AME evaluation address causation after a denial?
A QME or AME examines the worker, reviews the history and records, and gives an opinion on whether work caused, aggravated or accelerated the condition. Labor Code 4060 sets the route to this evaluation when compensability is in dispute. The DWC identifies reasonable medical probability as the standard of proof for medical opinions.
Who picks the evaluator depends on whether the worker has an attorney:
- With an attorney (Labor Code 4062.2): either party may request a three-doctor QME panel online. Each side may strike one name within 10 days of the panel’s assignment. The parties may also agree on an AME at any time.
- Without an attorney (Labor Code 4062.1): after the employer provides the panel request form and asks the worker to submit it, the worker has 10 days to do so before the employer may submit it instead. The denial notice accompanies the request. Once the panel is issued, the worker has 10 days to choose a physician, schedule the examination and notify the employer. If the worker does not notify the employer of the selection, the employer may choose the physician.
An orthopaedic evaluator weighs whether the mechanism of injury or exposure caused the disability or need for treatment. The analysis draws on evidence-based medical principles and, where relevant, peer-reviewed literature.
What caused any permanent disability is a separate, later question. Our article on causation of injury versus causation of permanent disability explains the difference.
What records and history does the evaluator rely on?
The evaluator relies on the worker’s history, the exam findings and the records the parties provide. Under Labor Code 4062.3, any party may give a panel QME treating records and other relevant medical and nonmedical records. With an AME, the parties agree on the records. Either way, the evaluator must identify everything received, reviewed and relied on.
The history, taken from a worker interview and the records, covers how symptoms began, job duties, past work, earlier injuries and general health.
Under 8 CCR 35, a party generally serves records on the other side at least 20 days before sending them to the evaluator. Under 8 CCR 38, however, missing records are not grounds for an extension. The evaluator reports on the information available and states that the opinions may or may not change after review.
Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) rules in 8 CCR 10682 list what a medical report should include where applicable. Among the items are the injury history, findings, diagnosis, cause of the disability and the reasons for the opinion.
What happens after the report is served?
Under Labor Code 4062.3, the evaluator serves the report and a summary form on the worker and the employer. Both sides then weigh the report with the other evidence. If they still disagree on causation, a workers’ compensation judge decides the issue. The evaluator gives a medical opinion and does not decide the claim.
Next steps can include:
- A supplemental report, due 60 days after a written request, or up to 30 days later by agreement (8 CCR 38).
- A deposition of the evaluator, generally within 120 days of the notice (8 CCR 35.5).
- An Application for Adjudication of Claim, if a case has not already been filed. A Declaration of Readiness to Proceed is used to request a hearing when the case is ready.
Which step fits a case is a legal question for an attorney or the DWC Information and Assistance unit.
Frequently asked questions
Does an AOE/COE denial mean my California workers’ comp claim is over?
No. An AOE/COE denial is not a final decision. Either side can request a medical-legal evaluation on compensability, and a workers’ compensation judge can decide disputes the parties cannot resolve. For a specific claim, an attorney or the DWC Information and Assistance unit can explain what applies.
Who chooses the evaluator after a denial?
The DWC Medical Unit issues a randomly selected panel of three QMEs. As the DWC notes, the list does not represent the employer or the insurer. With an attorney, each side may strike one name, or the parties may agree on an AME. Without one, the worker has 10 days from the panel’s issuance to choose and inform the employer, or the employer may choose.
How long does the report take?
The evaluator has 30 days after seeing the worker to complete and serve the report, under 8 CCR 38. On request, the DWC Medical Director can add up to 30 days for pending test results or a consultant’s report. For good cause, the extension is 15 days.
How OrthoLegal supports orthopaedic evaluations on denied claims
At OrthoLegal, one team handles scheduling, records intake and report support for orthopaedic QME and AME evaluations across Northern, Central and Southern California. Our focus is quality, on-time reporting.
Learn more about our orthopaedic QME evaluations, or call 213.947.0000 to request an evaluation.
Request an Evaluation (button, links to /for-applicants-attorneys/)
This article is general information about California workers’ compensation, not legal or medical advice. For advice about a specific claim, talk to your attorney or the DWC Information and Assistance unit.


